Pastors.com
Handling Criticism without Losing Your Cool

Do you want to know how to avoid criticism? 

Do nothing, say nothing, and be nothing. It’s really that easy. 

If you’re not doing anything to make an impact, no one will have any reason to drag you down. But the moment you become a leader and aim to do what God has called you to do, you will face criticism. It’s a guarantee. Pastor, criticism comes with your calling. But you don’t have to let criticism defeat you. 

I’ve faced a lot of criticism over the years. People criticized me for Saddleback’s “seeker-sensitive” approach, my interactions with diverse backgrounds and beliefs, and even the church’s rapid growth early on. Through all of it, I’ve learned that criticism often says more about the critic than it does about us. Understanding this has taught me a valuable lesson about loving my critics. 

Loving Your Critics

When you understand where criticism is coming from, you can respond with grace rather than defensiveness. 

Most critics are dealing with their own pain, insecurities, and unmet needs. They’re broken (just like the rest of us) and often have never truly experienced the love and grace of Jesus. They don’t feel love or acceptance, so they don’t want others to experience those things either. Hurt people hurt people.

Your critics don’t need your wrath. They need a massive amount of love. They have a giant hole in their heart saying, “Love me!” If they aren’t getting love, they figure they might as well get attention. So they spend their time criticizing others. 

To know how you should respond to critics, look at how Jesus handled his biggest critics, the religious leaders of his day. He didn’t eat with only the sinners of his day—he ate with the Pharisees too. Jesus loved the self-righteous critics of his day and so should we.

Handling Criticism

As you faithfully love your critics, you can learn from their criticism. Here’s a simple three-step formula that has helped me handle criticism in a Christ-honoring way.

  1. If it’s true, listen and learn from it. We need to develop an openness to learning from our mistakes and from others’ criticism. It takes inner security to do this, but it’ll pay dividends for years to come.

  2. If it’s untrue, ignore it. Most people tend to rehash criticisms over and over, bringing them up in their thoughts long after they should have buried the criticisms. But you need to remember—your critics often lash out at you because of something broken in them. It’s not about you.

    Paul dealt with criticism, but he realized he couldn’t fulfill God’s call on his life if he dwelt on those criticisms. So he wrote to the church of Philippi, “I am still not all I should be, but I am bringing all my energies to bear on this one thing: Forgetting the past and looking forward to what lies ahead, I strain to reach the end of the race and receive the prize for which God is calling us . . .” (Philippians 3:13-14 TLB). That’s a great lesson for us as we deal with critics today.

  3. Learn to judge yourself by God’s standards, not everyone else’s. You have an important choice when you respond to critics: You can trust God, or you can fear what others say.

    The Bible warns us, “Fear of man will prove to be a snare, but whoever trusts in the LORD is kept safe” (Proverbs 29:25 NIV). The moment we start worrying about what our critics think, we fall into a trap. The “fear of man” is a deadly trap for pastors that will cripple our ministries and distract us from our calling. But as long as we focus on pleasing God, we can face criticism without fearing failure.

    I try to live my life in such a way that one day, when I stand before Jesus, I’ll hear him say: “Well done, my good and faithful servant. You  have been faithful in handling this small amount, so now I will give you many more responsibilities. . . . Come, you who are blessed by my Father, inherit the Kingdom prepared for you from the creation of the world” (Matthew 25: 23, 34 NLT).

    That’ll be worth any criticism that comes my way. If Jesus is pleased with my ministry, it doesn’t matter what anyone else says.

Keep On

Paul reminds us in 1 Corinthians 16:9, “A great door for effective work has opened to me, and there are many who oppose me” (NIV). When you’re doing God’s will, you’ll often find yourself experiencing opposition.  

But don’t let criticism stop you from what God wants to do through your ministry. 

One of the most repeated phrases in the New Testament is “keep on.” We see it in Colossians 2:6: “You have accepted Christ Jesus as your Lord. Now keep on following him” (CEV). Ministry isn’t a 50-yard dash. It’s a marathon. It requires resilience in the face of criticism. If you’ve done the hard work of the three steps above, then it’s time to keep pressing on in the work God has called you to. 

Pastor, no matter what kind of criticism you’re facing right now, don’t let it keep you from what God has called you to do. Live for an audience of one. When your critics are right, learn from them. When they’re not right, forget about them. 

And keep on doing what God has called you to do.

Recent Articles

Preach to Build People Up

Preach to Build People Up

Pastor, people need to hear the truth. They also need to see the life God is calling them to live. I want my preaching to build people and help them believe they can take the next step.The Bible says, “Instead, speaking the truth in love, we will grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ” (Ephesians 4:15 NIV).Speaking the truth in love means telling people what they need to hear for their growth and caring about them as we say it. Kindness gives people what they need, not what they deserve. In preaching, that means challenging people and correcting them with their growth in mind.Give people a personal challengePaul writes, “I urge you to live a life worthy of the calling you have received” (Ephesians 4:1 NIV). He is challenging believers to make their lives count. We all need a cause or purpose that calls forth the best in us. Preach toward a cause bigger than self-interest. Call people to use their strengths to serve others and make their lives count. Challenge the best in them, then give them a clear next step.Give people confidenceWhen somebody believes in you, it brings out the best in you. Jesus gave Simon a new name and told him what he could become. Simon was impulsive, but Jesus saw his potential.People need encouragement. Our words can reinforce labels they already carry, or point them toward what God can develop in them. Help them see their potential and take a next faithful step.Give people honest counselThere is no progress without learning, and no learning without feedback. Proverbs says, “People learn from one another, just as iron sharpens iron” (Proverbs 27:17 GNT). People need someone who cares enough to tell them the truth, even when it hurts. When correction is needed, name it plainly.Aim to help a person change without condemning them. Affirm the person and correct the behavior. Speak the truth in love. That kind of correction can build people up.As you prepare this week, think of one person who needs a challenge, encouragement, or honest correction. Ask how your words can help that person grow. Build people up with kindness. Speak the truth in love.
Leave Some Room to Listen

Leave Some Room to Listen

“Find a quiet, secluded place so you won’t be tempted to role-play before God. Just be there as simply and honestly as you can manage. The focus will shift from you to God, and you will begin to sense his grace.” Matthew 6:6 (MSG)Pastor, by Monday morning, you may already be thinking about next Sunday’s sermon. Your phone already has messages waiting, and someone needs you to make a decision. Finding a few quiet minutes can feel like one more task you’re behind on.But look at Jesus’ invitation above. He asks you to come honestly, without playing a part. You don’t have to arrive with a lesson prepared or something helpful to say. You can tell God what’s really going on with you.You spend much of your week helping other people know him. He wants time with you, too.That can be easy to forget when every open moment fills with sound. You listen to a podcast in the car. You check your phone between appointments. Even when you’re alone, someone else’s words keep coming.There’s nothing wrong with listening and learning. But leave some room to listen to God. The sermon you’re studying won’t take the place of bringing your own heart to him.You may not have a quiet office or an uninterrupted morning. Could you close the door for a few minutes before returning calls? Or take a short walk and leave your phone behind?The point is to meet with God. Tell him what you’re carrying. Give your attention to his Word. Let there be a little silence without rushing to fill it.Before you open the next message today, take a few quiet minutes with him. You have people to care for this week, and your Father welcomes you into his care.
What Jesus Does When You Fail

What Jesus Does When You Fail

"The steadfast love of the LORD never ceases; his mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness." Lamentations 3:22-23 (ESV)Maybe you blew it last week, Pastor. A decision that hurt someone. A harsh word in a meeting. A weakness you swore you'd beaten, back again. And now it's Monday, and Sunday is already coming.Failure is isolating. When you're in the middle of a failure, you feel ashamed and just want to be alone. That's doubly true when you lead a church. You're supposed to be the person who’s whole.But Jesus is with you always, even in your greatest failure. To help you through your failures, he is doing three things:Jesus prays for you. Even before Peter had failed, Jesus told him, "I have prayed for you, that your faith will not fail" (Luke 22:32 NASB).Even at this very moment, Jesus is interceding—praying—for you. The Bible says, "He is able, once and forever, to save those who come to God through him. He lives forever to intercede with God on their behalf" (Hebrews 7:25 NLT).Jesus believes in you. In fact, he expects you to heal and recover. That's why, before Peter’s big failure, Jesus told him, "When you have repented and turned to me again . . ." (Luke 22:32 NLT). Jesus knew Peter would sin and fail and eventually come back to him.And Jesus knows the same about you. We all fail, and we fail repeatedly. Your biggest weaknesses are often habitual. The same one, again and again. But God isn't only there for the big, one-time failure. He's there for the mistakes you make over and over.Jesus shows you mercy. Jesus is more willing to show mercy than you are willing to ask for it. When you're down, he doesn't beat you up or add to your guilt. He saves you.In John 21, not long after Peter denied him, Jesus found Peter back in his fishing boat. Empty nets. A failed night. At dawn Jesus called from the shore and told Peter and the other fishermen where to cast. "So they did, and they couldn't haul in the net because there were so many fish in it" (John 21:6 NLT).That catch was Jesus' answer to Peter's failure. He is ready to do the same for you. He can do more in five minutes than you can do in 50 years of planning.And God's mercy toward you is not dependent on your performance. His mercies never come to an end. They are new every morning—including this Monday morning.You may be ready to give up on yourself, Pastor. Jesus isn't. He is praying for you, believes in you, and will always show you mercy. He has never been more faithful to you than he is today.
7 Reasons to Plan Your Preaching in Advance

7 Reasons to Plan Your Preaching in Advance

Every pastor knows the pressure of staring at a blank page and asking, “What am I going to preach this week?” If you wait until Monday to make that decision, you may spend half your preparation time deciding instead of preparing.Your people can tell the difference between a meal that was carefully prepared and one that was thrown together at the last minute. The same is true of sermons. No church grows healthy on a steady diet of spiritual fast food.Paul told Timothy, “Preach the word; be prepared in season and out of season; correct, rebuke and encourage—with great patience and careful instruction” (2 Timothy 4:2 NIV). Those two words matter: “be prepared.” Good preaching requires more than inspiration. It requires planning.Some pastors worry that scheduling sermons in advance will leave no room for the Holy Spirit to lead. But God plans. Jesus followed the Father’s timetable for his ministry, and Paul made plans for where he would preach and serve. You can pray, prepare, and still let God change the plan.Here are seven benefits of planning your preaching in advance.1. Give your church a balanced spiritual diet.Planning helps you see what you cannot see when you prepare just one week at a time. It lets you step back and ask whether your church is receiving a balanced diet from God’s Word.Look across the coming months. Are you giving people both doctrine and practical application? Are you balancing the Old and New Testaments? Are you helping people grow in worship, fellowship, discipleship, ministry, and mission?Pay attention to the tone of your preaching too. First Corinthians 14:3 says biblical preaching strengthens, encourages, and comforts. I think of those as building people up, firing them up, and holding them up.A church that only hears comfort will grow soft. A church that only hears challenge will grow tired. Your people need both comfort and challenge.2. Collect stronger material ahead of time.Advance planning gives you time to collect material long before you preach a message. If you know a series is coming, you can gather Scripture, illustrations, quotations, stories, and insights over several months instead of several days.I often prepared several possible series knowing I would not preach all of them that year. Nothing was wasted. The material I collected kept growing richer until the right time came to use it.Would you rather have five days or five months to prepare?3. Create room for greater creativity.Planning gives creativity room to work.During my years at Saddleback, when we knew where a series was going, our team could prepare testimonies, music, small-group material, memory verses, and other elements that supported what we were teaching. We could help the whole church move in the same direction.We never could have done that if I had decided everything at the last minute.4. Build momentum through sermon series.A series lets each message build on the one before it. People know where you are going, and they have a reason to return the next week.Momentum grows when you can say, “Next week, we’re going to look at this.” The congregation begins to anticipate what is coming, and each message adds weight to the larger truth you are teaching.That is difficult to create when every Sunday stands alone.5. Use special days strategically.Certain Sundays naturally bring more guests. Easter, Christmas, Mother’s Day, and other special days give you an opportunity to begin or announce a series that will bring people back.During my years at Saddleback, I often started a new series on Easter or announced one at Christmas Eve for the new year. I wanted to make the most of a day when people were already listening.A strong Sunday can introduce what you will teach in the weeks that follow.6. Help people invite others.When people know what you will preach, they can think of friends who need that message. If an upcoming week addresses resentment, worry, marriage, or another real challenge, your members can invite someone who is facing it.But they cannot invite people to a message they know nothing about. Advance planning gives your church time to pray, invite, and prepare.7. Reduce the stress of weekly indecision.Without a plan, the question “What am I going to preach?” follows you around all week.A lot of procrastination is really indecision. You are not unwilling to prepare. You simply have not decided where to begin.That is one reason I often preached in series. Instead of making a major subject decision every week, I made it several times a year. Once I knew the direction, I could spend my energy asking, “What does God say about this, and how can I communicate it clearly?”Start with one seriesIf you have never planned your preaching, don’t begin by mapping out an entire year. Start with one four- to six-week series. Then try planning the next three months.Pray over your plans. Invite input from trusted leaders. Hold every decision with humility, and let God redirect you when he wants to.Proverbs 21:5 says, “Careful planning puts you ahead in the long run; hurry and scurry puts you further behind” (MSG).Before this week gets away from you, block out time to look beyond Sunday. Sunday pressure will always come, but you do not have to let it decide your church’s spiritual diet.
© 2025 Pastors.com All rights reserved.
PO Box 80448, Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688