Much has been written over the past few years about the lack of male involvement and discipleship in the local church. Books on how to create engaging worship services that are gritty and rock n’ roll-ish, or how-tos on organizing “man” events of weight lifting, eating grilled beef, and drinking beer (sorry to my Baptist friends) are in abundance. But where are the men?
One would think that with the rise of church planting and prolific pastors and authors advocating for a type of “strong man” Christianity, we would see a difference in the membership of young fast-growing churches. But from mine and many others’ experiences, this trend of a manless Christianity has not only continued, but gotten worse.
We have done everything we can to open the doors for their acceptance and involvement, but when push comes to shove, the idea of staying at home watching ESPN, designing a logo for a new company, finishing a work project, or merely sleeping in, becomes top priority.
With this sad reality in mind, I want to share what I believe to be the 7 foundational actions we need to take as leaders to successfully engage the men within our churches.
Acknowledge Them
Simply put, the word “acknowledge” means to admit the existence of something or someone.
Men want to be acknowledged. They want to believe that someone knows they exist and cares for them. They have a desire to be known. When they come into church, go to a small group, attend a church event, or anything else for that matter, they are looking for you (pastor) and/or someone within the church to admit their existence.
This does not mean that you personally need to meet and shake hands with every single male in your church every Sunday. However, it does mean that you can and should empower the men already within your church to make contact with other men.
Remember, on any given Sunday there are men (young and old) that were brought to your church by their spouses, a potential girlfriend, the music, your preaching, or many other things. And although they stepped foot into the building, they are waiting to be sought out and acknowledged.
Bless Them
A couple of years ago my wife and I were interning at a larger membership church in California. One day the Senior Pastor of the church and his wife decided to take us out for dinner, hear our stories, pray for us, and offer to mentor us.
I was blown away.
The thought that the pastor and his wife wanted to bless my wife and I with not only a great dinner and encouraging conversation, but also with their investment into our lives, was encouraging. Their willingness to bless us opened my heart to trust them as leaders and fall more in love with their church.
Even though most men won’t often admit it, they crave to be blessed. They are longing to be taken out for a burger, invited to a BBQ or football party, or merely welcomed into your home. But they are waiting for you to invite them. They’re not going to invite themselves. They’re not going to seek after you and ask if they can come to your home, go to a sporting event, or get drinks at a local pub. But they will say “yes” when you take the first step. And eventually, they will say “yes” to being faithful to your church because you have been faithful to blessing them.
Challenge Them
This is a difficult topic to talk about because our culture has dumbed down the importance and differences of masculinity and femininity. But the reality is simple and obvious, men are looking to be challenged.They are looking to be given something to accomplish—something that will challenge them.
Now, this does not mean that every man in your church wants to build a new stage in your sanctuary or join a small group that meets at a local gym. It does mean, however, that every man in your church has been intricately designed by God to be passionate and skilled at something (or many things!). And because of this, they have an innate desire to be challenged within the realm of their passions and skills.
So, challenge them with something that will bring them joy and see results. Give them opportunities to succeed and/fail, and hold them accountable.
Here are a few examples I have seen done in different churches:
1) Challenge them to take their wife out to dinner once a week for an entire month and email you the benefits to their marriage.
2) Challenge them to pray with their kids each night for one week and see how it changes their relationships with their kids.
3) Challenge them to renovate the children’s wing of the church and have a “revealing day” where all the children and their parents get to see the renovations and meet the men who worked on their classroom or children’s sanctuary.
4) Challenge them create art, such as painting, photos, graphic art, and post it all throughout the sanctuary during a weekend of worship.
5) Challenge them to open up their homes and host BBQ’ing or renovation competitions for the men within their communities.
Let them Fail
In the process of challenging the men in your church, it is also imperative that you allow them to fail. Much of the reason why men are absent from church is because they are ashamed of their spiritual walks. They don’t pray much, they don’t love their families well, they don’t spend time reading their Bibles or talking with others about Jesus, and when they walk into the church, they feel condemned.
It shouldn’t be that way.
When you give a challenge to the men in your church and allow them to fail, you are in essence, living out the message of the gospel for them. You are saying to them, “I know you can be great. I know that God has gifted you and called you to something huge. And you know what? If you fail, it’s okay! There is grace for you when you forget to take your wife out for dinner. There is grace when you get angry at your kids. There is grace when you fail at a project. There is grace for you!”
When you let the men in your church fail, you are empowering them to experience the message of the gospel, which is often not what many of them experience when they step foot into most churches.
Listen to Them
Everyone man has something to say. And no, I am not talking complaints about how loud the music is on Sundays, or how boring your sermons have been recently. Rather, every man has joys, worries, complaints, past hurts, opportunities, etc., stirring within their hearts, but many of them have no outlet by which they can share these things.
They often hold a position in their job where they cannot speak their mind, and when they are home, they feel uncomfortable sharing what’s going on in their hearts with their spouses or friends for fear of being seen as a failure. However, many are willing to talk with a pastor that they trust and have built a relationship with. And it’s our calling to listen to them and hear them out.
With that said, don’t expect most men who are beginning to trust you and your church to set up a time for “counseling” or a one-on-one meeting right away. This is oftentimes too awkward for them. Rather, expect to spend time with them in a relaxed atmosphere and use that opportunity to ask pointed questions. It may take time, but trust me, they will eventually enjoy your willingness to spend time with them, ask questions, and genuinely listen.
Remember, most men don’t have an outlet for someone to listen to them. So be proactive in creating space for conversation, and rejoice in the small wins.
In a side note, when they share their thoughts about the church, your leadership, or their views of God and Christianity, take note. These are invaluable resources to learn from.
Pray with Them
When you meet with a man from your church or if he comes up to you during a Sunday service or small group meeting, take the time to pray with him. Take the opportunity, no matter the circumstances to let him hear your love for Jesus and offer time for him to pray as well.
Many of the men in your church have never seen Christianity modeled to them by a godly male leader. Besides hearing you or other preacher prays before their sermons, they may never hear another male pray out loud. But when you spend time praying with them, they will begin to see that an intimate relationship with Christ is not only healthy, but the greatest relationship in the world. They will experience fellowship with another man that is often not found in relationships outside the church. And ultimately, when you pray with the men in your church, they will be encouraged to spend time praying with others as well, including their wives and children.
Most of all, point them to the Father.
Every man needs a father. Every man craves the love, acceptance, and approval of a father. But in most situations, the men that are walking into your church are fatherless—both spiritually and literally. They have never experienced the loving grace of a earthly father and because of this absence, they struggle to understand the deep void they feel for a spiritual or heavenly Father as well.
Therefore, above and beyond every other “action” discussed in this post, your goal needs to be to point them to the Father. Point them to Christ Jesus. Point them to the message of the gospel that says they are anointed children of the most perfect and loving Father in the universe. Remind them every chance you get that God loves them, is proud of them, and has gone to the greatest lengths to be near to them.
Even the toughest and most non-emotional men in your church need to hear that God delights in them, is passionate about their lives, and wants the best for them and their families. They need to hear this. They need to see this. And they need to encounter this while they are with you and in your church. Because with out it, they are merely joining a social club that will not satisfy the deepest longings of their souls.
Current culture is doing its best to androgenize America. It’s bad for men and bad for women and children and bad for America.
I can’t stand the smoke machines at church and the Chris Tomlin sissy-music on Christian radio. Danny Gokey, etc. Men singing falsetto is bad for men.
Christian girls with their eyes closed and hands out while they sway gently to the cooing… let the ladies have their own church service.
Skinny jeans and man-buns and tight rolled pants.
Make it stop!
Men being in such settings is akin to college students attending grade school. It doesn’t fit and it’s unproductive for all parties involved.
‘Acknowledge Them’, ‘Bless Them’, ‘Pray with Them’, ‘Challenge Them’ etc. What – don’t you do this with women too? This article is so sexist.
As a male who unashamedly and unapologetically does not fit the gender stereotypes and expectations, I am tired of all the ‘gender stuff’ and sexism in the church. I have not regularly connected with church for a long time and I am unlikely to do so in the foreseeable future, mainly because of all the sexist stereotypes, assumptions and cliches. I am tired of being categorised by my gender. I am over the assumption that I will have something in common with someone simply because we are the same sex. Every time I contact a church to try to connect , the first thing people do is to try to draft me off into men’s groups/activities. Mostly (but not only) because of gendered environment that seems to be so much a part of church culture, I am unlikely to return to church anytime soon – if ever.
Who would you play ball with, a group of women or men?? Who would you go have drinks with, A group of men or woman? Who would you talk to about your problems, a group of women or men???? This isn’t sexist its true. You know and I know, it takes a man to truly raise a man, it takes a man to truly encourage a man. A woman encouraging is great but its nothing like having a man there who you can relate with on so many levels you cant relate to with women encouraging you to do more and be better. The bible says iron sharpens iron. Because if you put another metal to it, it may break or cause it to dull. Please just let the ego go like we all have to do and consider the article to be right, which i think it is…despite how i feel about.
hi, do you want to tell me there are churches that give beer to men during there services? what type of songs do they sing after taking the beer.
If you want more men at church, serve beer in the fellowship hall, show NFL games between services, serve burgers and pizza, build a gun shooting range on campus. There, guaranteed you have more men. Now what has that accomplished? How did Jesus attract men? He did miracles, He healed the sick, He blew Philip and Nathaniel’s minds with words of Knowledge, He challenged them to give up all, give up cars, football games, even families to follow Him. The He gave them an impossible task…win the world for Jesus. Then He said, WAIT till you are clothed with power at Pentecost. So what do you want, more men? Or more disciples?
Get rid of the emotionalism and the adult contemporary pop found in modern “worship” music, which are basically ballads that you can easily exchange the name of Jesus with that of your wife, husband, etc and it not miss a beat, forbid the women in the church from exercising ungodly control over the men (as the Bible demands) and focus on the inner life of the spirit instead of all the external hoopla. Then we’ll talk.
Do that and you lose me and a good part of the men in our 6000 member church. Jesus wept publicly. He jumped for joy and fist-pumped. He exulted. He hugged children. He was emotional. Don’t be a control freak, a misogynist and live in fear of women. Partner with women in the ministry as Paul did in Romans 16. I really enjoy the contemporary worship music (are you really that much of an old codger that you would rail against “modern music”?) If you want more men focus on reality, on the power of the Holy Spirit, on real healing, miracles, deliverance, spiritual warfare.
“Do that and you lose me and a good part of the men in our 6000 member church.”
Why is it so important that you keep them?
Serious question.
Did you notice that I said, you would lose me? I am not the pastor. My point was, emotionalism is a loaded term. There is nothing wrong with emotions. Guess is afraid of women exerting influence in the church. He is afraid of emotions. Any church that fears emotions and fears women, I want no part of. This is a grumpy curmudgeon that even rails against “modern music”. Sounds like my father when I was 16. To answer your question, the point of this article was how to increase the number of men and keep them involved. So why would you want to drive them away?
I dont believe he saying dont show emotions, but for us to stop going through the motions when we hear a song that makes us feel some kind of way for a moment and then go right to out sin when we are not at church or listening to those songs. i dont mind contemporary at all. Some times i prefer it. But we have to stop going through the motions and actually allow God to change us and get of His way.
Joshua, your blog is an excellent insight into men, along with how to approach and engage them. Your wisdom comes from listening and observing the work of the Holy Spirit in the lives of men. I applaud you.
I’m single, been going to the same church (of a, i don’t know, a few hundred per service in attendance) for several years and I don’t know a single person at church (not one!!), other than the pastors who greet you at the door. Not that I like it that way. Well, I’m pretty introverted, yet very capable. So its hard for me to reach out if someone doesn’t look open/receptive/approachable. I don’t seek the limelight or recognition. I don’t need it. I’m not the type one bit to butt into a group of people having a conversation. I stay out of other people’s business.
So after church, I kinda stand out in the commons area and just people watch for a few minutes. And I see people scurrying off this way and that way to get their kids, or they’re scurrying out the door for presumably family lunch plans. Or maybe other people are having a conversation with someone they already know. And that’s it, and I go about my way back home.
I have to agree with others here, that challenging me “to do” isn’t gonna light a fire to reach out and be involved. I just don’t feel any attachment. I know that I don’t lack with Christ, but if there’s one area I struggle with this, there’s no where in the world more than church, am I reminded what I don’t have (being single), than when I see such a concentration of guys with wives/girlfriends/kids. And so when the message is on family, or they are advertising a “men’s” group to presumably talk about being better fathers, or husbands, it just feels disenfranchising. So I go about my way til next Sunday, week after week.
I’m gonna say something that may be a little controversial on this website. And that is, maybe the pastoral message is where to “get men back”. I believe “purpose drive life” teaching has gone overboard being the central type of message week in and out. Constantly with these messages, am I to feel guilty for not “doing” or being driven in a certain way? At what point do I start tuning “purpose driven” out? I feel my church is selling family community more than Jesus sometimes. But its the same way with most other churches I’ve visited. So I just accept the fact and stick to where I’ve been going.
Consider the story of the Road to Emmaus in the Bible.
Luke 24:27 And beginning with Moses and all the Prophets, he explained to them what was said in all the Scriptures concerning himself… 32 They asked each other, “Were not our hearts burning within us while he talked with us on the road and opened the Scriptures to us?”
When I understood that, a “light” went of in my head and changed me. Jesus was teaching these two people about himself in the Old Testament. And their hearts were on fire! You know, I’m the same way. When I learned how some of these Old Testament stories are pictures of Jesus in one way or another, I’m extremely intrigued to learn what else is “under the hood” of these stories.
For example, Noah’s Ark. Noah’s Ark is Jesus. Passover is about Jesus. Why do Christians not celebrate Passover?? The menorah candle represents Jesus. When God challenged Abraham to sacrifice his son, the real meaning of the story is “this is your son right? your only son? the son whom you love?” You know how much its gonna hurt to sacrifice him? Now you can understand John 3:16 even more, is the feeling I get God is saying there. So even that story is about Jesus!! And its fascinating and exciting to learn about Jesus in those ways. And that is motivating!! But I NEVER EVER hear that in church. Its always “purpose driven” this way or that way we should do or be.
And so my point is maybe if pastoral messages were focused FULLY on Jesus and who he is, and not ourselves, that more hearts would be on fire, more often, to point of being motivated to be more involved. Trust the Holy Spirit to challenge.
Don’t worry, I stand around by myself at church too. Bring an iPad.
After being required to be social through my job, through kids, etc..,I don’t want to spend time talking and making small talk anymore,
you know, there’s something to your situation.
Matthew 11:28 says “Come to me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest.”
As I’m told, there’s only one thing in the bible to struggle for:
Hebrews 4:11 – Let us, therefore, make every effort to enter that rest, so that no one will perish by following their example of disobedience.
But with “purpose driven life” mantra, after a week of being driven daily sun up/sun down, come and hear a message of being driven more. Its frustrating. Just want to hear more on Jesus.
Thanks.
This is it exactly.
“after a week of being driven daily sun up/sun down, come and hear a message of being driven more. Its frustrating”
The nail on the head. We don’t need more to do, more challenges, more social activities. We sleep in because we are — as my grandma used to say — plumb tuckered out.
Tyler, As a fellow introvert, I can sympathize with tour situation. However, in your post you did not mention having an experience with a small group bible study through your church. The small group experience is the best way, and the only real way, to be connected to and build relationships with people. You seem to have a good grasp of scripture. You might consider approaching the appropriate pastor or leader at your church and seek to determine the best way to plug into the small group experience. You might be a good candidate to be a small group leader. Moses and God both admonished Joshua to be strong and courageous as he(Joshua) endeavored to live out the plan God had for his life. I would encourage you to be strong and courageous, to step out of your comfort zone and get involved with people. I stepped out of my comfort zone years ago and now I am a small group leader and adult volunteer leader in a youth group. I and others perform an important ministry supporting the youth pastor to perform his ministry. God doesn’t call the equipped, he equips the called.
As a christian, you have at least one spiritual gift. Find out what it(they) are and use it(them) for God’s glory. He will reward your efforts. Exercising your gift(s) will bring you alongside other christians using theirs, and together we will accomplish God’s will. It takes faith, strength and courage to do these things. It also takes action.
Good advice Kenneth. Find out your gift. It may be speaking in tongues. It may be interpretation of tongues. It may be prophecy. It may be word of knowledge (having supernatural knowledge of secrets of a person’s life) it may be a word of wisdom, it may be healing, it may be an extrordinary gift of faith, it may be the ability to work miracles, it may be discerning of spirits (detecting demons) and casting out demons. That is the whole list of 9 in 1st Corinthians 12. As Paul says preceding this, “But to each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good.” Paul’s advice was to “desire earnestly spiritual gifts, but especially that you may prophesy.” Let us desire earnestly spiritual gifts or as it is translated in some texts, covet earnestly.
“And so my point is maybe if pastoral messages were focused FULLY on Jesus and who he is, and not ourselves, that more hearts would be on fire, just as those two on the road to Emmaus were, more often, to point of being motivated to be more involved. Trust the Holy Spirit to be the one to challenge.”
You have explained the disease of the typical large seeker-sensitive church. It really isn’t about Jesus. It is about getting people in the door, getting enough money to keep growing, and giving people enough programs and activities to keep them happy and coming back.
Seriously – you want to challenge me to share their feelings? Do you know what a man is? You make men sound like teenage girls who talk about their date. I was agreeing with the article until I got to the rather feminine challenge part. It is so disappointing. How about challenge them to defend the nation ( politics, engaging the marketplace of ideas to show God’s truth, and yes, MILITARY SERVICE if they are young enough), how about challenge them to protect their communities (or do you teach that God doesn’t want us to serve outside of the church.) challenge them to protect their families (including owning a gun, and protecting modesty, protecting children’s masculinity and femininity. How about challenging the men to become experts in one area. Every church needs a man to can teach and respond to Mormons, JWs, Muslims, Roman Catholics, Hindus, Buddists, etc. It would be nice to see a pastor actually encourage men to devote years to become the churches experts in one area. Instead of just sitting in the pew and trying to be a good little boy. I’ve met so many Christians and good churchmen who run in terror at the slightest challenge from the world. A godly man rises to the challenge.
WOW. We should challenge them to carry guns and fight wars? I don’t think Jesus made that challenge, But he did challenge us to love our wives like Christ loved the church. To show love and compassion. To be faithful, To treasure our families. In the Bible, military service was never mentioned in any way to show you are a Christian. That is totally an American Christian definition. As for some of your other challenges, I’m all for that.
You say at the very end ” A godly man rises to the challenge.” I think that is the whole point of this article. Challenging men to be Godly – So he is giving some ideas.
I don’t think carrying a gun and fighting wars was Craig’s point. Rising to the challenge definitely is. I served our country for three decades as a Christian Airman. I handed our country a blank check, redeemable up to and including my life if necessary. Sometime THAT is the price one must pay in order to ensure the freedom and safety of one’s family. But even in that role, I stood for Christ and tried to live the kind of life where people would see the great things Jesus has done in my life…and would want “some of that” in their own. Not every man needs to serve in the military, but EVERY man needs to serve in his family, and in his church. As the old hymn goes, “Rise Up, O Men of God!”
Spot on! Our God is a MIGHTY fortress! A WARRIOR and a LION! Not a candy-ass. The challenges you outline are the RIGHT kind of challenges that can get men engaged in not only taking an active and leading role in our churches, but being the LION in their family! Thanks for you spot on analysis and advice. Rock on my brother!
Suppose in a little large church like 1000 or above, how is it possible for the pastor to acknowledge all of the men on a Sunday, even if the church is 200 and above. But your other points are really good workable to certain extent. If you keep doing all by yourself then may drain out too, so it should be balanced I guess. This is how I do, I bring all the men once a week and fellowship and during that time we share problems, requests, testimonies of victory and joy, meditate, discuss and do different things and also go out with motorbikes almost every quarter or so. The men are very strong now and they themselves lead the group without sometimes…
Another reason why I question a “local church” should ever need to be more than a couple hundred in size. There is no way a pastor can truly disciple a church of a 1000.
Thats where the Elders and the Minister and the brothers title or no title come in and help acknowledge the other brothers. its not just the Pastors job to connect with the men and the people but the other leaders as well that say they support their pastor and the mission of the church
I disagree with a lot of points made above. As a man who has been a Christian for 20 years, here is my feedback:
1). I don’t want to be acknowledged. I want to be left alone. I have to be social and talk 50 hours a week or more already.
2). I am not longing for more social activities like a BBQ or whatever.
3). I do not need anymore challenges or to be held accountable. I’ve got a job, a wife, and three kids. I have enough challenges.
4). Listen to me, see number one. I have enough talking in my life.
5). I do not need to be prayed with. I pray all the time. We had an entire reformation to get the pastors out from between me and God.
Here is what I do need:
I don’t want to sing love songs.
I don’t want to see boxes of tissues in every row.
I don’t want to votive candles, doilies, flowery designs on the tables,
I want solid expository teaching from the pulpit.
I want an educated pastor who won’t tell me that the way we do church today is normative. I know it isn’t. I also know that there were Christians who went to live in the desert without a community (sometimes a community formed around them) and they were no less Christian for it.
Sounds like you need to find a ME church. Doesn’t it?
Hm. Figures. Normal church person answer.
Look. The point of the article is how to get men into the church. It is addressed to pastors. Each subpoint ends with “them.” I am part of the “them.” I don’t need more stuff to do and deal with on a weekly basis. I have enough challenges in my life.
Most men I know and am friends with spend 50 hours working, then go home and spend time with kids and wives. It is a satisfying life, we don’t need more. We are happy with the status quo. Even my non Christian friends behave this way. No one needs more things to do and social activities to go to. We might all get together and hang out on a friend night with the wives and kids. Kids play, we have dinner, that’s enough.
I don’t need someone to listen to me. We don’t. We have joys, pains, hurts, etc…but that makes us who we are. We don’t feel the need to share. Why share? Why spend time on the pain? They’re the things we carry with us, the things that make us who we are. If we lose them, we lose ourselves.
If I wanted a ME church it would be easy to find. There are lots of them. A dime a dozen. That wasn’t my point,
You really missed the point.
“I want solid expository teaching from the pulpit.”
Amen. You nailed it. It is very hard to find solid expository teaching from the pulpit in large seeker-sensitive churches these days.
Look up Apostle Tommy E Quick
I’m not sure I see very much in this article that applies to males only. But all good stuff.
Paige, you are absolutely right. I wanted to narrow the scope down mainly because there has been a trend over the last 40+ years of men not actively engaging in the community of believers, even when their spouses or children have. This is not to say that these “actions” don’t apply to women, singles, divorcees, etc., Rather, it is a conscious effort for churches to engage men who have historically been distant from church, and to do so in a loving and consistent way that is without gimmicks.
Thanks for your comment!
How do you challenge the single men in your church?
Bob, thanks for commenting. I believe these “actions” still apply to any man (or even woman!), single or not. Of course, how they are actually brought out within a church context can vary. But my hope is that these actions speak to God-given desires in every man, no matter their relational status.